The classifications of Bordeaux
A Bordeaux classification assesses an estate, not the bottle in front of you. And the same word on the label can mean two very different things: in the Médoc, a ranking drawn up in 1855 that has been attached to the estate's name ever since; in Saint-Émilion, by contrast, an assessment provided for in the appellation's specifications, carried out afresh every ten years, for which an owner has to apply with a dossier. Anyone who knows which of the two mechanisms lies behind a “classé” reads a label differently.
Two ways to be classified
The Saint-Émilion list is the more flexible of the two cases. It is provided for in the specifications of the appellation, has existed since 1955, can be revised every ten years and is administered by the Institut national de l’origine et de la qualité. An estate that wants to be included collects an application dossier, pays the procedural fee and submits it by a deadline. That none of this is a mere formality becomes clear when two editions are compared: in 2012 there were 18 houses in the upper tier of “premiers grands crus classés” and 64 in the tier below; in the 2022 edition there are 14 and 71. A rank that is granted anew every ten years can therefore shift — and one can also simply stop applying for it.
In the Médoc it is the other way round. A ranking was drawn up there once, in 1855, and it still stands today; there is no application procedure for it. What this list originally reflected, and what such a ranking says about the current vintage, we cover elsewhere: what the usual pointers are worth when choosing. Alongside it, the region has other lists, such as those of the Crus Bourgeois and of the Graves.
What actually goes into the score
What such an assessment is made up of is revealing. The Saint-Émilion rules name four criteria. The first, and at fifty per cent of the final score the weightiest, is the quality and consistency of the wines, tested on samples. The second is a study of the estate's reputation. The third describes the estate itself, including its vineyard base, the fourth its management in the vineyard and in the cellar.
Half the score thus comes from the glass, the other half from everything a house has built up over decades. That is not a flaw in the procedure, for consistency across ten or fifteen vintages is hard to achieve and an honest piece of information. It simply answers a different question from the one someone has when standing in front of the shelf.
What a rank actually rests on
The difference from the designation of origin is easily overlooked here. An appellation is mapped; it applies to an area of land. A classification applies to an estate, in other words to a name — and a name can buy and sell plots without its ranking changing in the slightest. A classification therefore reliably tells you something about the history of a house, and only indirectly something about the soil on which the grapes of the vintage you are drinking grew. Anyone who wants to know what is in the bottle soon ends up one level further down, at the individual plot.
How we order quality
Our wines appear on none of these lists, and we are not working towards it. At LaSuite aux Conseillans we arrange them not in ranks but as movements of a suite — voices of equal standing, each with its own character. On five hectares of vines we farm sixteen plots and vinify them separately before deciding what belongs together; that is the resolution at which quality can be judged here at all. The one piece of information no list provides, we provide ourselves: whether a wine is ready to drink now. Only then do we release it for sale, and the risk of the years of ageing beforehand stays in the cellar, not with the buyer.