Tasting wine
Anyone who opens a bottle and drinks straight away is not tasting – they are drinking. Tasting means paying attention in a particular order: first the eye, then the nose, and only after that the mouth. This order is not a ritual from wine courses; it protects against a very specific mistake – a later impression overwriting an earlier one before you have even consciously registered it.
What the eye really reveals
Colour and clarity give a first, rough indication – of age, of grape variety, sometimes of the ageing. But no more than that: anyone who infers quality from colour alone mistakes a peripheral piece of information for the result. A slight haze is rarely a fault either – in gently filtered or unfiltered wine it simply belongs. The real reason to start with the eye nonetheless lies elsewhere. A glance needs no preparation and tires nothing – unlike the nose and palate, it is just as reliable at the second tasting of an evening as at the twentieth. So you do not start with the eye because it says the most, but because it loses the least.
Why the nose comes before the mouth
Most of what we perceive as taste actually arises in the nose – via the throat, retronasally, while the wine is already in the mouth. Anyone who drinks straight away still skips none of this; they only change the order in which the information arrives, and that is precisely what costs something. If you first smell the glass at rest, the nose picks up fine, volatile aromas that would be drowned out in the mouth by acidity, tannin and alcohol. And the nose tires: after a few deep breaths over an intense wine, it registers markedly less than at the first sniff. Anyone who waits to smell until the wine is already in the mouth has used up this first, most sensitive perception without having made use of it. Serving temperature also plays a part here: served too cold, a wine holds back its volatile aromas in the glass – aromas that could have said something even before the first sip.
What expectation changes – and what it doesn't
Sensory experiments have shown for decades that expectation really does change taste, not just the description afterwards: the same wine is rated differently depending on what it says on the label or what it cost. This is not proof that taste is arbitrary, but that part of what we perceive comes from the head and not from the glass. For your own tasting, this means nothing dramatic: occasionally tasting a wine you know blind is often an eye-opener. The choice of glass is a different matter: its effect is purely physical and not a matter of expectation – the shape determines where the aromas are directed in the glass before the nose even passes judgement.
Why a second glass says more than the first
Anyone who tastes a wine only once is tasting a single moment in its development – in the glass a wine changes within minutes, and with decanting even over hours. An impression from the first minute is therefore not a wrong one, but an incomplete one. For us, this is part of our practice: a bottle we open to form a judgement stays in the glass over the evening, because a single sip rarely gives all the information you need to truly assess a wine. In the end, tasting is not a performance but a method of not deceiving yourself – sense by sense, in the order that loses the least.