TIME & RESPONSIBILITY

How a Bordeaux tastes, from young to mature

From young to mature, what changes in a Bordeaux is less the quantity of aromas than their order: at first dark fruit, oak spice and a cool, almost stony note lead; later leather, tobacco, undergrowth and dried fruit come to the fore. In between, many wines go through a period in which they give remarkably little — and it cannot be dated.

What changes is not only the nose. Colour, tannin and aroma move together, because the same compounds are involved.

What leads in the first years

In the first years after bottling, fruit and oak are in the foreground in a red wine from Bordeaux. Both are at their most distinct at this point, and both grow quieter. The fresh, juicy fruit note depends on a group of volatile compounds, the esters, which slowly diminish in the bottle — the warmer the wine is stored, the faster. Oak behaves similarly: where new barrels were used in the élevage, vanilla, toast and spice are clearly recognisable early on and over the years become part of the texture rather than appearing as a flavour of their own. A young Bordeaux therefore often seems spicier and at the same time more restless than the same wine a decade later, simply because more is up front at once.

The phase in which a wine gives little

Between the two states, many wines go through a period in which there is hardly anything to be had. In Bordeaux it is called “âge ingrat”, the awkward age: the wine is not faulty, not tired and not merely closed — it simply says very little. To this day this has not been explained. The most widespread interpretation is a matter of overlap: the youthful aromas have largely faded, the mature ones have not yet developed, and a gap remains in between. Whether it occurs at all, when and for how long differs from wine to wine and cannot be predicted. For your own bottle, one thing above all follows from this: an evening on which a wine disappoints is not yet a verdict on it.

Where leather, tobacco and undergrowth come from

These notes seem as if they are added at some point. In fact they form over years in an environment that almost no oxygen reaches, and only become perceptible once the fruit loses its dominance — they do not appear, they emerge. At the same time, what you see and feel changes: pigments and tannins combine into larger molecules, the colour moves from a violet rim to garnet and later to brick, part of it settles as sediment, and the tannin feels softer because it has literally become larger. Colour, texture and aroma in a maturing red wine are therefore not three observations but three views of the same process.

What this means for your own bottle

The inconvenient consequence is that you cannot get both states from one bottle. Anyone who wants to experience the young, dark fruit has to open early and accept the tannin; anyone looking for leather and undergrowth gives up the fruit in exchange. A wine does not have the one right stage of maturity, but several good ones, and which of them suits you is a question of taste, not of quality — how far along a wine is depends on its condition anyway, not on its age. In practice this means having more than one bottle of a wine that matters to you and opening them years apart; there is no more reliable way to find your own preference.

This is also why we only release our wines once they begin to show their drinking maturity. Anyone who buys a bottle young also buys the years in which it says the least. When they are over is written on no label; you notice it when the fruit steps back and the wine nonetheless does not grow quieter.

Navigate the curriculum